Menu
Franchise Stores Better Look Out: Independents Are Benchmarking

Franchise Stores Better Look Out: Independents Are Benchmarking

By: Roy Davila
Published on: November 3, 2026

The Short Answer

Yes, franchise stores should pay attention. Not because independents are getting bigger, but because the good ones are getting sharper. They benchmark their stores against peer dealers, find the profit they are leaving on the table, and fix it month after month.

That is the real competition now. It is not the store with the most inventory or the biggest ad budget. It is the store that knows its numbers better than you know yours.

This post is for both sides of the street. If you run a franchise store, here is what you are up against. If you run an independent, here is why the gap you used to assume was there may be smaller than you think.

What Changed on the Independent Side?

For a long time, the picture of an independent dealer was a lot, a phone and a gut feeling. Some stores still run that way. But plenty of independent dealer principals and GMs stopped guessing a while ago.

They started treating the store like a business with a financial statement, not a pile of deals. They look at gross per unit, days to turn, reconditioning cost, F&I income per retail unit and expense as a percent of gross. Then they ask the harder question: compared to who?

That last question is where benchmarking comes in. A number by itself does not tell you much. Your front-end gross might feel fine until you see what similar stores are holding. Your recon spend might feel normal until you see it sitting well above the group.

Once a dealer sees that, it is hard to unsee. And a dealer who knows exactly where they are behind is a dealer who is going to close that gap.

Doesn't My OEM Already Give Me Benchmarks?

If you run a franchise store, you probably get a composite from your manufacturer, maybe sit in an OEM-run 20 Group, maybe hold a seat on a dealer council. Those are useful. They tell you how you stack up against other stores carrying the same brand under the same program rules.

But that view has limits. Everyone in that room sells the same new product, chases the same incentives and answers to the same factory. A good share of the conversation can end up being about the manufacturer, not about how to run a tighter store.

Independent dealers don't have a factory composite to lean on, so the best of them built their own view. In an ARC 20 Group, their numbers sit in front of an outside moderator whose focus is the store's profitability, not a factory objective.

Think of it this way. An OEM composite tells a dealer how they compare for that brand. The independents in a 20 Group are learning how they compare as a business. That is the gap franchise stores should be watching.

Those independents are asking sharper questions. How is the used car department really performing? What does the service drive look like on its own? Is the F&I office producing like it should, or has everyone just gotten used to the number?

Where Is the Profit Usually Hiding?

Every store is different, but the leaks tend to show up in the same places. When dealers compare their statements side by side, these are the areas that usually start the longest conversations:

  • Used vehicle operations: aged inventory, reconditioning cost and time, and how much gross gets given back as units sit.
  • Service and parts: effective labor rate, technician productivity, and how much of the store's fixed expense the service department actually covers.
  • F&I: income per retail unit, product penetration and how consistent the process is from one manager to the next.
  • Expenses: personnel, advertising and floor plan costs measured against gross, not just against last year.

None of this is new. Every GM knows these are the levers. The difference is whether you are measuring them against a peer group or against your own memory of last quarter.

That is the point for franchise and independent stores alike. Benchmark your store against peer dealers and find the profit you are leaving on the table. It is usually there. The question is whether you go looking for it.

What Does an ARC 20 Group Actually Do?

An ARC 20 Group is an executive peer group for independent dealer principals and GMs. Dealers bring their numbers, compare performance with other stores and talk openly about what is working and what is not.

The numbers run through LinuS®, ARC's financial benchmarking software. LinuS® shows dealers where their store sits against the group, so the conversation starts with facts instead of opinions.

The groups are led by ARC's Executive 20 Group Moderators, Mike Hirschfield and Roy. Their job is not to sell you something. It is to know your numbers well enough to ask the uncomfortable question, then help you build a plan around what the numbers show.

That is the part dealers tend to value most. A report can show you a problem. A good moderator and a room full of peers can help you figure out what to do about it on Monday morning.

The groups are built for the people who run the store. That matters. When the people at the table can make decisions, the conversation turns into action. You can see how the groups work on our 20 Groups page.

What Should Independent Dealers Take From This?

If you run an independent store, the title of this post is not meant to puff anybody up. It is a reminder. The independents who are gaining ground are not doing it by accident. They measure, compare and adjust.

If you are not doing that yet, the franchise store down the road is not your biggest problem. The independent across town who already is might be.

Independents also have an advantage worth protecting: speed. There is no factory sign-off needed to change a pay plan, rework a recon process or tighten up the F&I menu. When the numbers point to a problem, you can move fast. Benchmarking makes sure you are moving in the right direction.

And if you are already benchmarking, the next step is the same one franchise stores face. Take the numbers seriously enough to change something. A benchmark you look at once a month and file away is just paperwork.

The Bottom Line

Franchise stores better look out. Not because the independent across town has a bigger lot, but because the good ones know their numbers cold and know how they compare.

It cuts both ways. Any store, franchise or independent, that sits down with peers, looks at its statement honestly and acts on what it finds is going to be harder to compete with.

If you run an independent store and want to see where it stands, start with an ARC 20 Group. Bring your numbers and find out what you are leaving on the table.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a 20 Group for car dealers?

A 20 Group is a peer group of dealers who share financial results and compare performance. The goal is to see where your store is ahead or behind similar stores and learn from what other dealers are doing. A moderator usually keeps the group focused on results.

How is an ARC 20 Group different from an OEM 20 Group?

An OEM 20 Group compares stores that sell the same brand under the same manufacturer programs. An ARC 20 Group is not run by a manufacturer, so the focus stays on running a profitable store across sales, service and F&I.

Can independent dealers join an ARC 20 Group?

Yes. ARC 20 Groups are built for independent dealer principals and GMs.

What is dealership benchmarking?

Dealership benchmarking means comparing your store's financial and operating numbers against peer dealers instead of only against your own past results. It shows where you are leaving gross, overspending or underperforming in sales, service and F&I. The value comes from acting on what the comparison shows.

What is LinuS®?

LinuS® is ARC's financial benchmarking software. It powers ARC 20 Groups by letting dealers see how their store's numbers compare with peer dealers. That gives the group and its moderator a factual starting point for every conversation.

How do I find out if an ARC 20 Group is right for my store?

Start by reaching out to ARC through arcnation.com. The team can walk you through how the groups work and what you would bring to the table.

Get In Touch
Get In Touch